Reproductive consequences of nesting site decisions in a marine toadfish (Porichthys notatus)

Abstract

Animals should favour breeding locations that maximize their lifetime reproductive output. Parents ought to rear young in sites that positively affect offspring but sometimes these same sites inflict costs on parents. How parents balance their own needs against those of their offspring when selecting a site for reproduction remains unclear, particularly in animals that provide extended parental care at one location. Further, few studies have linked variation in life history traits to reproductive site choices within a single species. In this thesis, I addressed both knowledge gaps by studying the plainfin midshipman (Porichthys notatus), a marine toadfish where fathers provide sole parental care to broods of young in intertidal and shallow subtidal nests for up to two months. In Chapter 2, I measured the costs incurred by caring males and the benefits conferred to offspring in nest sites along a tidal gradient. Males suffered similar rates of body condition deterioration in all nests across the intertidal gradient. Young developed more quickly in intertidal nests compared to subtidal nests, but broods in the highest intertidal nests suffered the highest mortality rates, despite receiving more parental care from the males at these nest sites. We found the most competitive males in lower intertidal nests, a trend that agrees with life history theory—in species with relatively slow offspring development, parents should accrue greater reproductive benefits from nest sites where offspring benefits are highest. In Chapter 3, I describe a laboratory experiment designed to examine how warm water and air exposure (two abiotic conditions that vary dramatically within the intertidal) affect development and survival of plainfin midshipman young, and how these effects vary with maternal traits. Exposure to warm water enhanced embryonic and larval development rates; this effect was attenuated by air exposure. Juveniles raised in warm water also exhibited superior swimming performance, while air-exposed young suffered higher mortality rates. Although larger juveniles emerged from larger eggs, development rates were similar across egg sizes. Offspring survival increased with maternal body condition in cold water but decreased with maternal body condition in warm water. Juvenile body sizes increased with maternal condition in cold water without emersion, and in warm water with emersion—the two ecologically relevant rearing environments. Thus, low condition mothers might accrue greater benefits by depositing their eggs in nests at higher tidal elevations—where development is more rapid—further supporting the idea that among-individual variation in the expression of life history traits might influence nest site preferences in these fish. In sum, my research (Chapters 2 & 3) elucidates the link between life history traits and the spatial component of animal reproductive strategies.