Responsibility and Justice: Considerations for Increasing Access to Prenatal Care. An Interpretive Descriptive Study of Health and Service Providers Understandings of Inadequate Prenatal Care in Hamilton.

Abstract

Prenatal care (PNC) is an essential health service that can reduce adverse health and social outcomes through prevention, detection and treatment of abnormalities of pregnancy. It offers an opportunity to mitigate the impact of the Social Determinants of Health (SDoH) on individual patients through advocacy and referral to social services. Despite a publicly funded health care system in Canada, disparities in access to PNC persist. Much is known about the barriers to PNC and client experiences of inadequate PNC (IPNC). Very little is known about care provider perspectives of IPNC, what should be done about it and are the barriers to doing it. The goal of this project was to address this gap in knowledge to inform the development of novel care delivery models that could reduce disparities in access to PNC in Hamilton. Using a Critical Theory lens, I conducted an interpretive descriptive study using individual interviews and focus groups with health and social service providers in Hamilton to explore their understandings of IPNC. Participants viewed IPNC as a small but important phenomenon disproportionately impacting people who are marginalized. The experience of IPNC is chaotic, worrisome and joyful for providers. An interdisciplinary, midwifery-led outreach PNC model would better meet the needs of the client population and providers alike. A Community Centred Care model of PNC embodies and enhances participant suggestions for addressing IPNC. Access to abortion, postpartum care and newborn apprehension require special attention. Peer participation and the impacts of patriarchy and racism must be addressed in the development of future PNC models. The ways in which participants described and proposed intervening in IPNC revealed an individualized understanding of the SDoH that is paralleled in existing research on IPNC. This conceptualization of the problem obscures the root causes of disparities in access and warrants future consideration.