"Danger" and the "Dangerous Case": Divergent Realities in the Therapeutic Practice of Traditional Birth Attendants in Garhwal, India

Abstract

Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs) are the primary health care providers for women at the time of childbirth in many parts of the world. In India, particularly in remote areas such as Garhwal, these women play a key role in maternal health. Training programmes for TBAs can lead to dramatic reductions in neonatal mortality as well as in maternal morbidity and mortality, due to improved hygienic practices at the time of delivery. Yet training programmes for TBAs often lack sociocultural relevance, and fail to incorporate an understanding of the TBAs' perceptions of the process of pregnancy and delivery. Understanding more about the role of the TBA as a diagnostician and a decision-maker within a given sociocultural context can make such training programmes more culturally congruent. This research report describes the way in which TBAs (dais) in Garhwal interpret obstetrical complications, and how they make decisions regarding the need for cosmopolitan medical care. TBAs in Garhwal interpret obstetrical complications using a variety of explanatory models, arising from an understanding of health and illness which shows influences of Vedic, Ayurvedic, folk and cosmopolitan medical models. These explanatory models often led to a perception of "danger” and the "dangerous case" which is widely divergent from the cosmopolitan medical model. Specific areas are identified where the dais' interpretation of "danger" was particularly divergent from the cosmopolitan medical model. These areas of conceptual conflict result in diagnoses and treatment procedures which can lead to significant delays in the woman receiving needed cosmopolitan medical care. The third stage of action-research process is the development of a participatory training programme, in which the TBA is an active participant. The aim of the training programme is to move towards a shared perception of risk regarding major obstetrical complications.