Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
http://hdl.handle.net/11375/11912
Title: | Legal Scholarship as a Source of Law |
Authors: | Shecaira, Fábio P. |
Advisor: | Waluchow, Wilfrid J. |
Department: | Philosophy |
Keywords: | Legal reasoning;sources of law;content-independent reasons;legal scholarship;formalism;Other Philosophy;Other Philosophy |
Publication Date: | Apr-2012 |
Abstract: | <p>This thesis advances a number of claims, some conceptual, some empirical, some normative. The conceptual claims are concentrated in chapters 1 and 2, where a general account of the notion of a source of law is provided. Roughly, sources of law are documents or practices (e.g. statutes, judicial decisions, official customs) from which norms can be derived that function as sources of content-independent reasons for judges to decide legal cases one way or another. The remainder of the thesis is dedicated to discussing whether legal scholarship – or, more precisely, a particular type of legal scholarship that can be described as standard or doctrinal – is used as a source of law (as the concept is defined in chapters 1 and 2) in modern municipal legal systems. The conclusion that legal scholarship is used as a source of law (and thus as a source of content-independent reasons for action) may come as a surprise to those who associate recourse to legal scholarship by judges with judicial activism. It will be argued, however, that legal scholarship can plausibly be used to mitigate discretion. Indeed, it is precisely because it can be used in this way that judges sometimes refer to scholarship deceptively and suggest that it limits discretion in situations in which it in fact does not.</p> |
URI: | http://hdl.handle.net/11375/11912 |
Identifier: | opendissertations/6842 7864 2514884 |
Appears in Collections: | Open Access Dissertations and Theses |
Files in This Item:
File | Size | Format | |
---|---|---|---|
fulltext.pdf | 645.98 kB | Adobe PDF | View/Open |
Items in MacSphere are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.